Everyone is Talking About Interest Rates - So Let's Talk
If you bought or renewed a few years ago, you probably remember when mortgage rates started with a 1 or a 2. Those days are behind us for now. Rates today sit well above where they were in 2020 and 2021, and plenty of homeowners have felt it at renewal.
It's natural to look at today's rates and think, "Maybe I'll wait until things come back down before I make any big moves." We hear it all the time.
Here's the thing about The Smith Manoeuvre™, though. It was never built around a perfect rate. The strategy is designed to adapt to whatever the market is doing, and in some ways, a higher-rate environment actually works in your favour. Let's look at why.
First, a quick refresher
The Smith Manoeuvre uses a readvanceable mortgage, which pairs your mortgage with a line of credit. Every time your regular payment reduces your mortgage principal, that same amount becomes available on the line of credit. You borrow it back and invest it in income-producing investments held in a non-registered account.
Because that money is borrowed to earn investment income, the interest on it is tax-deductible. Over time, the non-deductible debt on your home is converted into tax-deductible investment debt, and you're building an investment portfolio alongside your home equity.
The interest on the line of credit is covered by the growing efficiency of your mortgage payment. Each month, a little more of your payment goes to principal and a little less to interest. That increase is readvanced, with a portion covering the interest on the line and the rest going into your portfolio. There's no extra money coming out of your pocket.
The interest rate touches two parts of that picture: what it costs to borrow, and what you get back at tax time. And that's exactly why the strategy holds up when rates move.
When rates are higher: your tax deduction grows
When rates go up, the interest on your investment loan goes up too. On its own, that sounds like bad news. But because that interest is tax-deductible, a bigger interest bill also means a bigger deduction, and more coming back to you at tax time.
How much you save depends on your tax bracket and how much interest you're paying, which means the value of the deduction moves with the rate.
Interest still costs you money, of course, but the government is picking up a meaningful share of it, and that share grows as rates rise.
What you do with that refund is up to you and your advisor. Some homeowners put it toward the mortgage, which frees up more room to readvance and speeds up the conversion. Others invest it directly. Either way, it's money working for you that wouldn't exist if your mortgage were simply sitting there.
One honest note: when rates are higher, less of each mortgage payment goes to principal in the early years, so the amount you readvance each month may be smaller. The conversion can move a little more slowly, while each deductible dollar is worth more. That's the strategy adjusting rather than stalling.When rates are lower: more goes into your portfolio
When rates come back down, the picture shifts in a different direction.
Borrowing costs less, so a smaller share of each month's readvance is needed to cover the interest on your line of credit, and more of it goes straight into your investments. Lower rates also mean more of each mortgage payment goes to principal, which frees up more room to readvance each month.
Your tax deduction is smaller in a low-rate environment, simply because you're paying less interest. But you're building your portfolio faster and converting your mortgage debt more quickly.
Either way, the strategy keeps moving
Put the two side by side and you can see how the strategy balances itself out:
Higher rates mean bigger tax deductions and more back at tax time.
Lower rates mean cheaper borrowing and more going into your investments each month.
The structure stays exactly the same. What shifts is where the benefit shows up. That's why there's no need to time the market or wait for rates to land in a certain range before getting started.
What matters more than the rate
If the rate isn't the deciding factor, what is? In our experience, the homeowners who get the most out of The Smith Manoeuvre have a few things in common, and none of them have anything to do with timing the market:
Time. The strategy rewards patience. The longer you stay with it, the more your portfolio has a chance to grow and the more of your mortgage gets converted. Ten years or more is a good starting point.
Stability. Steady income and some breathing room in the monthly budget make it much easier to stay the course.
Comfort with the ups and downs. Markets go through rough patches. Homeowners who can ride those out without selling tend to come out ahead.
Consistency. The real advantage comes from letting the strategy run month after month, through every kind of rate environment.
Over a 25-year mortgage, rates will rise and fall many times. A strategy that only works under perfect conditions wouldn't be much of a strategy at all.
A few things to keep in mind
The Smith Manoeuvre is flexible, but it still deserves care:
Investments can go down as well as up. Your investment loan stays the same whether your portfolio is having a good year or a tough one.
Clean records matter. To keep the interest deductible, the money you borrow needs to go directly into income-producing investments. Using the line of credit for everyday spending can muddy the waters at tax time.
Registered accounts don't qualify. RRSPs and TFSAs already come with their own tax advantages, so the deduction applies to non-registered investments only.
It works best as a team effort. Your mortgage broker, financial advisor and accountant all play a role. A Smith Manoeuvre Certified Professional™ brings those pieces together and helps make sure the strategy fits your situation from the start.
The best time to start
It's easy to put big financial decisions on hold until conditions feel just right. But with The Smith Manoeuvre, waiting for the perfect rate mostly means giving up years of potential growth.
Whether rates are up, down or somewhere in between, the strategy has a way of putting them to work. What matters most is having a plan that fits your life, and the time to let it do its job.
Curious what The Smith Manoeuvre could look like for you in today's rate environment?
Connect with a Smith Manoeuvre Certified Professional™ to start the conversation.
This article is for general information only and isn't financial, tax or legal advice. The example above is a simplified illustration; your results will depend on your own rates, tax bracket and investments. Speak with qualified professionals about your situation.
If you bought or renewed a few years ago, you probably remember when mortgage rates started with a 1 or a 2. Those days are behind us for now. Rates today sit well above where they were in 2020 and 2021, and plenty of homeowners have felt it at renewal.
It's natural to look at today's rates and think, "Maybe I'll wait until things come back down before I make any big moves." We hear it all the time.
Here's the thing about The Smith Manoeuvre™, though. It was never built around a perfect rate. The strategy is designed to adapt to whatever the market is doing, and in some ways, a higher-rate environment actually works in your favour. Let's look at why.
First, a quick refresher
The Smith Manoeuvre uses a readvanceable mortgage, which pairs your mortgage with a line of credit. Every time your regular payment reduces your mortgage principal, that same amount becomes available on the line of credit. You borrow it back and invest it in income-producing investments held in a non-registered account.
Because that money is borrowed to earn investment income, the interest on it is tax-deductible. Over time, the non-deductible debt on your home is converted into tax-deductible investment debt, and you're building an investment portfolio alongside your home equity.
The interest on the line of credit is covered by the growing efficiency of your mortgage payment. Each month, a little more of your payment goes to principal and a little less to interest. That increase is readvanced, with a portion covering the interest on the line and the rest going into your portfolio. There's no extra money coming out of your pocket.
The interest rate touches two parts of that picture: what it costs to borrow, and what you get back at tax time. And that's exactly why the strategy holds up when rates move.
When rates are higher: your tax deduction grows
When rates go up, the interest on your investment loan goes up too. On its own, that sounds like bad news. But because that interest is tax-deductible, a bigger interest bill also means a bigger deduction, and more coming back to you at tax time.
How much you save depends on your tax bracket and how much interest you're paying, which means the value of the deduction moves with the rate.
Interest still costs you money, of course, but the government is picking up a meaningful share of it, and that share grows as rates rise.
What you do with that refund is up to you and your advisor. Some homeowners put it toward the mortgage, which frees up more room to readvance and speeds up the conversion. Others invest it directly. Either way, it's money working for you that wouldn't exist if your mortgage were simply sitting there.
One honest note: when rates are higher, less of each mortgage payment goes to principal in the early years, so the amount you readvance each month may be smaller. The conversion can move a little more slowly, while each deductible dollar is worth more. That's the strategy adjusting rather than stalling.When rates are lower: more goes into your portfolio
When rates come back down, the picture shifts in a different direction.
Borrowing costs less, so a smaller share of each month's readvance is needed to cover the interest on your line of credit, and more of it goes straight into your investments. Lower rates also mean more of each mortgage payment goes to principal, which frees up more room to readvance each month.
Your tax deduction is smaller in a low-rate environment, simply because you're paying less interest. But you're building your portfolio faster and converting your mortgage debt more quickly.
Either way, the strategy keeps moving
Put the two side by side and you can see how the strategy balances itself out:
The structure stays exactly the same. What shifts is where the benefit shows up. That's why there's no need to time the market or wait for rates to land in a certain range before getting started.
What matters more than the rate
If the rate isn't the deciding factor, what is? In our experience, the homeowners who get the most out of The Smith Manoeuvre have a few things in common, and none of them have anything to do with timing the market:
Over a 25-year mortgage, rates will rise and fall many times. A strategy that only works under perfect conditions wouldn't be much of a strategy at all.
A few things to keep in mind
The Smith Manoeuvre is flexible, but it still deserves care:
The best time to start
It's easy to put big financial decisions on hold until conditions feel just right. But with The Smith Manoeuvre, waiting for the perfect rate mostly means giving up years of potential growth.
Whether rates are up, down or somewhere in between, the strategy has a way of putting them to work. What matters most is having a plan that fits your life, and the time to let it do its job.
Curious what The Smith Manoeuvre could look like for you in today's rate environment?
Connect with a Smith Manoeuvre Certified Professional™ to start the conversation.
This article is for general information only and isn't financial, tax or legal advice. The example above is a simplified illustration; your results will depend on your own rates, tax bracket and investments. Speak with qualified professionals about your situation.
Read Next
Let's Talk About The Budget Trap for Financial Literacy Month
What Happens to Your Retirement Plan When Your Mortgage Gets More Expensive?
Stop Chasing the Lowest Mortgage Rate
It's a Spooky Time to be a Homeowner in Canada